SeeWAIS
2026-11-15
SeeWAIS Research · Independent research on how AI answer engines name and cite businesses.

Compare tools that show where AI answers get facts wrong about your brand

Which tools actually surface wrong facts in AI answers — mention trackers, one-off audits and manual checks compared on evidence, claim grading and price, with vendor prices checked October 2026.

Most tools sold as "AI visibility" or "brand monitoring" answer the question one step before the one you are asking. They report whether an assistant named you, how often, and in whose company. The tools that show where an answer gets your facts wrong are a shorter shelf, and they share one method: keep the answer word for word, then check each claim against your own pages. Three routes do that — a one-off measurement that grades every claim, a human audit that reads your case, or an evening of manual checking. Dashboards handle the first question well and are largely blind to the third.

A mention tracker tells you that an assistant said something about your business. It does not tell you whether the something is true.

Three kinds of wrong, and only one is a lie

In our published sample report — a real client run, pseudonymised — we extracted 333 factual claims the assistants made about one med spa and checked every one against the business's live site: 178 were correct, 14 flatly contradicted the page, and 141 were not stated anywhere on the site.

That split is the whole job. The 14 wrong claims mostly came from an assistant answering from memory that could not identify the business at all, then asserting it could not confirm services the site stated plainly. The 141 unverifiable claims may be entirely true and simply never published in a form a machine can read. Wrong and unverifiable need different fixes, and a report that merges them into one score cannot tell you which you have. These figures describe one business measured once, not an industry rate.

The comparison, grouped by what a tool can actually grade

Route Price Can it show a wrong fact? What you receive
Mention and sentiment dashboards $29–$399 a month No — it scores presence and tone A dashboard, no deliverable to keep
Google Search Console $0 No — it shows which of your pages AI features surfaced Impressions by page
Manual spot checks $0 Partly — only in answers you happened to ask for Your own notes
One-off measurement with claim grading $4.99 here; $29–$99 self-serve elsewhere Yes — each claim marked against your live page Every answer verbatim, a PDF and a report link
Human-delivered audit $99–$4,500 Yes, if the human reads your case A written interpretation and priorities
Agency retainer $1,000–$5,000 a month Sometimes, as a by-product of monitoring Monitoring plus implementation

Vendor prices were read from the vendors' own pricing pages in October 2026; our price is current as of 21 October 2026. The supplier-by-supplier ledger keeps the detail, and what each tier contains is the page to read first if you are choosing on budget.

The gap in the top row is structural, not a bug in one product. Trackers watch a stream of answers for signals: did the brand appear, how was it described, which competitor sat beside it. Grading a claim needs your site as the reference document and a judgement on each sentence, which means the raw answer text has to be kept and the cited page opened. A dashboard summarising thousands of checks a month is not built for that, and blurring the two is how visibility and accuracy get sold as one thing. The monitoring tools we checked are good at their job; this is a different job.

Five questions that sort the shelf in minutes

Ask every vendor the same five things, and verify the answers yourself rather than accepting a sales page:

  1. Will I see the answers word for word? A paraphrase destroys the evidence: "charges £90" and "may charge around £90" are different findings. The measures worth comparing all start here.
  2. Will each claim be marked against my page, or only counted? Correct, contradicts and not stated are three outcomes, not one.
  3. Will you give me the URLs the answer drew on? Those URLs are the fix list; a score without them leaves you guessing. Why the cited page is the thing to change.
  4. Is each question asked three times? One answer is an anecdote; three tell you whether the claim is stable. That is why our method repeats your three key questions.
  5. Is a re-measure included? If not, nothing can ever be shown to have moved, and you should budget for one.

The test that separates these tools is simple: ask each one to show a claim the assistant got wrong, the answer it came from, and the page that supplied it. A tool that cannot produce those three things is not measuring facts.

Prices, and what the monthly fee buys

The dedicated trackers are sold by subscription: Otterly.ai from $29 a month (Lite), Semrush's AI-search tier at $165 a month billed annually, Ahrefs Brand Radar from $50 a month at index level and $199 a month for prompt-level tracking, and Peec AI around €90–€499 a month in third-party listings. That buys cadence — the same measurement repeated, somebody watching the change. Below the retainer tier it does not buy the fixes, and it does not grade a claim by default.

A year of retainer at $1,000–$5,000 a month runs $12,000–$60,000 before implementation. For a single-location business that has never measured once, that is monitoring of a problem whose shape is still unknown. The cheaper sequence: measure once, fix what it found, re-measure to check. One-time report or monitoring sets the two purchases side by side without a preference.

Where our own one-off measurement sits

We sell one thing, so declare it: $4.99 once, no subscription. A report asks 30 questions — 25 unbranded buyer questions across four buying stages, plus 5 that name your business directly — across five live AI surfaces: ChatGPT (searching the web), Gemini (searching the web), Claude (from memory), Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode. That produces 146 AI answers, all reproduced verbatim — the 96 model answers individually graded, the 50 search answers mechanically checked — from 242 API calls. Your three key questions are each asked three times to test stability, and METHOD v1.3 is published and frozen, so the counting rule can be checked rather than trusted.

What it does not do: it reports, it does not fix. It is one measurement with no re-measure bundled in; a second run is another $4.99. Delivery is about 20 minutes, with a full automatic refund if the report is not delivered within 24 hours of payment and a 30-day money-back window beyond that. The PDF is yours to keep; the private report link stays live for 12 months. It is closer to a census than a dashboard — and a dashboard is what you graduate to once you have a baseline worth watching. What GEO means in practice is the background if the terms are still new.

Which route fits which business

  • You suspect one specific wrong claim (a stale price, a closed service, an old address): the DIY check, today, in the how-to-check walkthrough. It costs an evening and one document.
  • You have never measured and want the whole picture: a one-off measurement. Fix, then re-measure.
  • You want the interpretation written for you: a human-delivered audit at the lower end of that band, with the evidence requirements above written into the brief.
  • Several locations, markets, or an agency: snapshot first, monitoring after. A time series over no baseline is decoration.

Limits that travel with every number

Every figure here describes a sample of questions asked at a moment in time, logged out, with no attribution to revenue. Assistants change their answers; one reading is a snapshot, not a trend. No tool on this list can promise that a corrected page will be quoted next month, and a vendor who does is describing something they cannot deliver — the free routes exist so you can check the claim yourself before paying anyone.

What does AI say about your business?

The free check reads your site and shows you the exact questions we would ask — before you enter any card details. The full report is $4.99 once.